Mundek convinced her to take a chance with life by coming with him into the sewers. It tells of a small group of jews who were found in hiding beneath the city streets by a man named leopold socha, a sewer worker. A heartfelt, oscarnominated movie based on the reallife suffering of jews in world war ii, critically dissecting it seems almost. Attempting to write about in darkness is a tricky proposition. Polish, yiddish, ukrainian, german in november 1941, following the occupation of the city in june, the nazis herded up and killed jews in lvov, poland, barbered beards in public and butchered, confining the remainder inside a ghetto. In darkness, agnieszka holland, 143 mins 15 the independent. The film, adapted by david f shamoon from robert marshalls book in the sewers of lvov, seems to be operating on two levels. It tells the true story of a dozen of so polish jews who hid in the sewers for more than a year with the aid of leopold socha robert wieckiewicz, a polish catholic sewer worker who, as he put it, knew the tunnels better. The more heroic a story, the more it demands to be told in a style that resists the obvious heroic mould. In darkness presents him, appealingly, as a sort of accidental schindler a thuggish parttime criminal who undergoes a moral rebirth and. Out of the chaotic early scenes and the darkness of the underground locations, distinct characters emerge, most notably, the conflicted socha, whose transformation is both gradual and credible. Based on a true story, it takes you into the sewers of. What starts out as a cynical business deal turns into an unlikely alliance and friendship as socha helps the jews survive the sewers and evade botnik and the nazis. At two and a half hours, it could have used some trimming, but.
From acclaimed director agnieszka holland, in darkness is based on a true story. But mundeks group enlisted the help of leopold socha, the chief supervisor of the lvov sewers. In darkness directed by agnieszka holland written by robert marshall book, david f. Angels in the dark the amazing story of survival in the sewers of lvov.
In darkness is based on the true story of a group of people who survived the violent destruction of the jewish ghetto by escaping into the sewers of lvov, poland. Famed polish filmmaker agnieszka holland tells one such story that combines all three elements in her latest film, in darkness. In darkness, much like other films about the holocaust, will undoubtedly manage to touch a nerve in us all. In darkness by agnieszka holland agnieszka holland. Lundy lundy is known for the gritty down to earth situations his characters suffer through. He persuades socha to help him enter, then escape from the camp, compelling the sewer worker to take ever greater risks. Even in darkness director agnieszka holland acknowledges that one may ask if everything has now been said on this subject. W ciemnosci is a 2011 polish drama film written by david f. The last survivor of the group, krystyna chiger, published a memoir of her experience, the girl in the green sweater. After the opening credits, we see a shot of a woman being strangled.
In darkness received the golden teeth award for most interesting feature film the audience jury prize in chicago, as the best foreign production, at the 23rd polish film festival in america in chicago in nover 2011. Benno furmann mundek margulies, agnieszka grochowska klara. Leopold socha, a sewer worker and petty thief in lvov, a nazi occupied city in. In darkness tells the true story of leopold socha who risks his own life to save a dozen people from certain death. Seems a pov shot from the perspective of the strangler. The film takes place mostly in the dank and foetid darkness of the. Shamoon country poland release date 10 february 2012 usa limited release in darkness is a 2011 polish drama film directed by agnieszka holland. Krystynas complete story can be read in robert marshalls book, in the sewers. Raw, harrowing, and peopled with vibrant characters, in darkness is an extraordinary book about the cruelties of man and nature, and the valiant, ongoing struggle for a countrys very survival. Shamoon wanted to make sure the escapees werent depicted as. The story follows an individual group of jews who evade the nazis once the ghetto massacre begins. It tells of a small group of jews who were found in hiding beneath the city streets by a man named leopold socha, a. Initially only interested in his own good, the thief and burglar hides jewish refugees for 14 months in the sewers of.
Based on robert marshalls book in the sewers of lvov this is. Intolerable, painful and realistic the tragic attempted extermination shows the heroism of some polish citizens who sacrificed their own well being for the sake of others. He persuades socha to help him enter, and then escape from the camp, compelling the sewer worker to take ever greater risks. If you want lots of action mixed with great characters then read w.
Agnieszka holland s in darkness, inspired by the real exploits of a polish sewer worker and sometime burglar named leopold socha, who helped jews during the nazi occupation of lvov now. Cecilia benzaquen, the daughter of klara keller and mundek margulies, two of the survivors portrayed in in darkness, has lived in seattle for the past 27 years. In the realm of holocaust survival tales, in darkness occupies a rather unusual position in that virtue and vice are attributed to jews and nonjews alike. In darkness is a pitiless glimpse into the inferno, into hell not only on earth but below it. Brooke has now been reinstated as a special agent and is about to get her first real case to investigate a high profile overdose murder, a bad batch of heroin, a bikie gang and of course brooke and declans budding relationship. In darkness, a nominee for best foreign language film at this years oscars, is elegantly presented, chock full of moments of dreadful suspense in a horrible milieu in which everyone is ready to take advantage of anyone at a moments notice, and buoyed by strikingly naturalistic performances. Agnieszka holland wins best director for in darkness at the valladolid festival in spain in late october 2011.
In darkness is based on an extraordinary true story, chronicled in the book in the sewers of lvov by robert marshall. Shamoon, based on the book in the sewers of lvov by robert marshall in the nazioccupied polish city of lvov, jews have been herded into the ghetto, which is set for. As the darkness of its title suggests, we are witnessing a hell on. Shamoon drawing on the book in the sewers of lvov by robert marshall, obligingly supplies the. Set largely in the dank sewers of the polish city of lvov during the nazi occupation, agnieszka hollands in darkness. For 14 months they endured unimaginable hardship surving through the help of a polish sewer worker named leopold socha. One of the most compelling true stories has opened in theaters. You may not have heard of leopold socha, but youll never forget him after seeing in darkness, the latest and, you could argue, the best film from polish director agnieszka holland. This film is based somewhat on the book, in the sewers of lvov, by robert. It benefits from expert handling by veteran polish director agnieszka holland angry harvest and an outstanding script by firsttimer david f. In darkness a complex docudrama about wwii refugee aider leopold socha robert wieckiewicz offers exactly that. One of the group, mundek margulies, a con man who hides deep reserves of courage under a breezy manner, deeply distrusts socha. Holland wisely leaves the dialogue primarily in polish, though many languages are used. Benno furmann as mundek margulies and agnieszka grochowska playing.
In darkness is based the nonfiction book in the sewers of lvov, by robert marshall. But david f shamoons richly characterdriven screenplay based on robert marshalls book in the sewers of lvov makes this project feel original and worthwhile. Hollands adaptation of robert marshalls book in the sewers of lvov is a worthy addition to the pantheon of holocaust cinema. Robert wieckiewicz as leopold socha benno furmann as mundek. Socha, however, makes a deal with a rich jew in mundeks group to keep their whereabouts secret. Shamoon, in darkness nominated for an oscar for best foreign language filmearns its name because most of its action takes place in the murky, claustrophobic, grotesque sewer system below the lvov ghetto. Shamoon drawing on the book in the sewers of lvov by. Mundek heard of a shaft from a flat into the sewers and helped the digging, using knives, forks and small tools. In darkness is based on the book in the sewers of lvov 1990 by robert marshall.
Mundek falls desperately in love with feisty young klara, and decides on a foolhardy mission. The world war ii holocaust film is called in darkness and tells the incredible story of the attempted slaughter of jews in a polish city. Based in part on robert marshalls 1991 book in the sewers of lvov and penned by firsttime screenwriter david f. In darkness considering the harrowing truestory origins of her latest wwii extreme survival story, polish director agnieszka holland no doubt intended for in darkness to be arduous. The oscar nominee for best foreign language film lives up to its title but finds joy and human nobility amidst the blackness. In darkness a true story of a group of polish jews hiding for 14 months inside city sewers by patrick ivers, film critic 2011. Shamoon, who adapted the nonfiction tome by robert marshall. In darknesss genius is to treat the dimness of the sewers and the darkness of the movie house as one.
Agnieszka hollands in darkness, based on the true story of a polish gentile who kept a dozen jews alive in the sewers of lvov, is as close as anyone has come to depicting the most infernal event of human history without trivializing it a moral accomplishment no. Gelsenzentrum gelsenkirchen angels in the dark krystynas. In darkness is based on the book in the sewers of lvov 1990 by robert. The script by david f shamoon based on robert marshalls book in. A dramatization of one mans rescue of jewish refugees in the germanoccupied polish city of lvov. This book follows on from where we left brooke and declan at the end of exposed in darkness. In darkness, by nick lake, is an intertwined story about a 15 year old boy, shorty, who gets trapped in a hospital after an earthquake in haiti, and toussaint louverture, who is leading one of the greatest slave revolutions in haiti in the late 1700s. A nonfiction book called in the sewers of lvov tells of sochas jews and their remarkable survival, but it was out of print when rookie scriptwriter david f shannon bought amazons last copy. From acclaimed director agnieszka holland, in darkness is based on a. Nevertheless, when the nazis strike, socha helps the jews, including two young children, escape into the sewers. In in darkness, set in the sewers of lvov, poland, a righteous gentile.
1152 1035 506 1570 818 1209 290 151 230 1196 1169 460 809 280 535 308 589 2 1656 401 1260 875 1108 691 464 1253 919 1499 1390 1598 775 1626 647 328 678 840 1046 912 1383 235 1115 166 743 396 1271 519 1045 1083